Founded in 2008 by the P.E.N. Center Germany For the Freedom of the Word
Carola-Stern-Stiftung en.carola-stern-stiftung.de

Home  /  Freedom of Opinion and the Press

Foundations and the Present

Freedom of Opinion and the Press

A fundamental right is not a possession but a claim that someone has to enforce. What Article 5 covers, where the limits lie and by what means pressure is applied today.

What Article 5 Really Covers

In Article 5 the Basic Law guarantees freedom of opinion, freedom of information, freedom of the press and freedom of broadcasting and film, along with freedom of art and science. There shall be no censorship, it says expressly, and that sentence means prior control by the state. It does not mean that everything is allowed. Limits are set by the general laws, the protection of minors and the right to personal honor, which is why slander, incitement to hatred and defamation remain punishable. The real work lies in weighing these positions against each other, and courts do that case by case. Anyone who believes a fundamental right is a free pass misunderstands how it is built.

More interesting than the prohibition side is the protection side. Press freedom covers not just publishing but also gathering information, the confidentiality of the editorial office and the freedom to organize a newsroom as you see fit. Without these preliminary stages, the right to print would be worthless, because there would be nothing to print. That is why searches of newsrooms, the skimming of connection data or pressure on informants are so delicate. They do not interfere with the result but with the conditions under which a result can come about at all. Modern forms of obstruction start exactly there, because they are harder to grasp in legal terms.

What Pressure Looks Like Today

The classic censorship office has become rare, but its function has not. It has been replaced by procedures that look legal and still serve the same purpose. These include intimidation lawsuits, in which wealthy plaintiffs bury a small newsroom in proceedings until the money runs out. They include accreditations that are no longer granted and advertising budgets that suddenly land elsewhere. They include spyware on reporters' phones that exposes sources without anyone having to kick in a door. And they include online campaigns that follow a single journalist until she switches topics.

The insidious part is how the costs are distributed. The attacker needs little effort, while the target has to invest a great deal to hold out. A lawyer costs money that a freelance author does not have. A lawsuit takes months in which no research gets done. In the end there is often no verdict but a quiet withdrawal, and that is statistically invisible. That is why the foundation also helps with court costs and legal advice when a case falls within our purpose. How these awards work is explained on the page Foundation Goals.

Protecting Sources Is a Craft, Not an Attitude

Anyone who works with informants bears responsibility for their safety, and that responsibility does not end when the text appears. In practice sources are seldom unmasked by betrayal but by carelessness. A photo with metadata, a chat history in cloud storage, an appointment in a shared calendar, a follow up question by unencrypted mail: any one of these details can be enough. Add patterns nobody considers, such as the fact that only three people had access to a particular document. Good protection of sources therefore begins before the first conversation, with the question of which traces that conversation will leave at all. And it requires that you properly destroy research material instead of keeping it out of sentiment.

A second point concerns the promises you make. Never promise a source more protection than you can actually deliver. Explain what happens if an authority seizes documents and what you will do in that case. Make sure the person assesses the consequences of publication realistically, because many underestimate them massively. Also record what was discussed, but in such a way that the note itself endangers nobody. Such agreements seem bureaucratic, yet they are the difference between an informant with a job and an informant in court.

Censorship that works is never spoken aloud. It shows in the fact that a topic is no longer offered because the trouble is not worth it. Nobody states this calculation out loud, and that is why nobody corrects it either.

Mistakes That Keep Happening

The most common mistake is assuming that a problem is a one off. When two newsrooms receive the same odd request in the same month, that is no coincidence but a pattern. The second mistake is going it alone: out of shame or pride, those affected talk to no one, and the matter escalates quietly. The third concerns documentation, because whoever does not secure threats and does not file dated screenshots is left without evidence later. The fourth is a technical one, namely the belief that a password replaces a security concept. And the fifth is time: many look for support only after deadlines have passed and nothing can be repaired anymore.

Publishers and broadcasters have a list of their own. Freelancers are often left alone in lawsuits even though they worked on assignment. Legal protection is not planned for, fees do not cover the risk, and security training is seen as a luxury. Anyone who regularly handles sensitive topics should settle these points by contract before the first lawyer's letter arrives. It is considerably cheaper to clarify in advance who bears which costs than to argue about it afterward. That applies as well to exiled colleagues who report for German media on their countries of origin and carry a markedly higher risk in doing so. What to keep in mind here is described on our page on Writers in Prison and Writers in Exile.

What Is at Stake

A society does not notice the loss of press freedom on the day it occurs. It notices it years later, when nobody can give information about a building permit, a clinic or an arms deal, because the relevant research never took place. First local newsrooms disappear, then correspondent posts, then the willingness to take on powerful people. What remains is a public that is formally free and in practice silent. Carola Stern knew both sides, the state ordered speechlessness in East Germany and the voluntary kind in the West, and she considered the second more dangerous because nobody resists it. Her life story is on the page Carola Stern: A Portrait, and if you want to support the foundation's work, you will find the ways on the home page.